PSYC2500
Tips for Article Summaries
I. Rationale
Throughout your college career, you will be required to do a lot of
reading and a lot of writing. Sometimes, high school doesn't adequately
prepare you for the types or amount of reading and writing required at
the college level. This requirement is designed to help you learn to read
scholarly articles and how to get and summarize the important information.
II. Selecting A Journal Article
The more care you take in selecting an article to summarize, the easier
the reading and writing will be. You can find articles at the library and
over the internet. First, let's address the library. You can get assistance
finding appropriate journals by consulting the reference desk. The library
staff can show you to the professional psychology journals. Some hints:
1. If the journal has the words "journal" and "psychology"
in the title, it's probably appropriate.
2. If the journal has glossy pictures or looks like you'd get it at a magazine
rack, it's probably not appropriate.
3. Psychology Today is not an appropriate journal!
Some appropriate journals include:
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Journal of Social Psychology
American Psychologist
Journal of Clinical Psychology
Psychology in the Schools
Psychology of Women Quarterly
If you're not sure the journal is appropriate, check with me before
writing the paper. Note that you are best served by getting your article
several days before the paper is due. Waiting until the last minute will
probably hurt you.
So how do you choose a journal and an article? Well, to start with, try
to find something of interest to you. Psychology is a broad field -- you
can explore topics such as child development, love, hate, education, mental
illness, dreams, biological bases of behavior, criminality, etc. You can
find something of interest by flipping through a journal (e.g., Journal
of Abnormal Psychology for articles on mental illness and treatment),
or by using the computer system in the library or over the WWW.
A second consideration when selecting the article is the length of the
article. Many students try to look for the shortest possible article. This
makes sense but should not be the only consideration. Writing a three-page
summary of a three-page article is somewhat pointless. Also, some journals
publish short book reviews or obituaries. These items rarely make for good
summaries. Consider the content of the article when you look at the length.
I'd suggest you (GASP!) read the article before copying it and committing
yourself to it.
On this read-through, determine whether the article is really about what
you expected. Get an idea of whether you understand it, at least basically.
Is there a study described in the article? You can determine this by looking
for sections entitled "Method," "Results," and "Discussion."
If so, this may help you structure your summary. If there are three or
four studies conducted in the article, it may be difficult to summarize
adequately in a brief paper.
So what if you decide to use the internet? The Web has the advantage of
convenience but requires more diligence to be sure you select an appropriate
journal article. I recommend against using internet search programs (e.g.,
Lycos, Excite, Yahoo, etc.), because you will find websites more often
than journal articles. Instead, access Galileo through the Library section
of the VSU website (http://www.valdosta.edu). Select the "Journals
and Publications" option and set it to search for "full text
articles" when you conduct your search of the specific topic that
interests you. It does you little good to print out only a summary of the
article; you need to read the whole article of interest, be sure to check
that it comes from an appropriate professional journal, as described above.
III. Reading the Article
Students get into trouble when they try to write their summary as they
read an article for the first time. It's also my opinion that simply reading
and using a highlighter has limited value. Students have a tendency to
highlight either nothing or 90% of the article! If you're not sure how
to read and summarize an article, I recommend taking notes on a separate
sheet of paper as you read. Don't copy passages from the article; instead,
just jot down important points and facts in your own words so you understand
your notes.
So what points are important?
In an article presenting a research study (the easiest to summarize), there
are typically four main sections: an introduction, method, results, and
discussion sections. In the introduction of the article (everything prior
to the section titled "Method"), look especially for the hypothesis
or hypotheses. These are the assumptions the study is designed to test.
The earlier part of the introduction typically presents previous research
leading up to the current study. Highlight terms you don't understand and
try to derive the meaning from context or a dictionary. When you write
your paper, explain what these terms mean in your own words.
In the method section, note who participated in the study and what they
were asked to do. Were they asked to fill out surveys? Did they perform
a task? Was deception used to keep the participants from knowing the true
purpose of the study? Remember that these methods are supposed to test
the accuracy of the hypotheses mentioned earlier. Do they seem to do so
adequately?
The results section can be intimidating. It is in this section that statistical
analyses are presented. These analyses are conducted to evaluate the data
acquired through the methods used in the prior section. These analyses
lead to the conclusions drawn in the next (discussion) section about the
hypotheses that are the point of the whole study. Crystal clear, right?
Anyway, in the results section, I am not overly interested in all the specific
numbers and types of statistical wizardry performed. But you should look
through this section and especially note the tables and figures presented.
Even without a strong knowledge of statistics, you can usually get a sense
of whether the results seem to support the authors' hypotheses. If you
can't, have no fear -- the authors will draw conclusions in the next section.
In the final section, the discussion section, the authors draw conclusions
based on the study's results. Often they decide whether their hypotheses
are supported or rejected (note: no one ever proves anything in
psychology!), and opine about the implications of the results. Report the
author's conclusions and maybe draw some of your own.
Some articles may present more than one study or none at all. In the former
case, you need to summarize all the studies. In the latter case, try to
get an idea of the purpose of the article (the writer's thesis, much like
a paper you'd write for English class), and the points used to support
the writer's position (or thesis). Again, be sure to define all relevant
terms in your own words.
IV. Writing the Summary
To avoid problems of unintentional plagiarism, I suggest that you put
the article aside when actually writing up your summary. If you've taken
notes as I suggested in the earlier section, you can use those notes to
write your summary. If you took care to take notes in your own words with
good clear definitions of the terms (again, in your own words), then you
will not inadvertently use the authors' words in writing up your summary.
Yes, it's plagiarism even if it's unintentional. Some students benefit
from writing an outline of the summary first. Do this if you like. I will
even look at the outline and give you my opinion on it if you show it to
me at least a day before the paper's due.
You also want to avoid writing the summary as you read because you will
follow along with the article far too closely. Recall that this is meant
to be a summary. Think of it this way, when you read a newspaper or magazine
article you find interesting and later on tell a friend about it, do you
typically get the article and read along with it to describe it to your
friend? Likely not. You summarize the high points, with enough background
info to help your friend understand what the article's about before hitting
the major points you found of most relevance. Do the same thing here. Cover
the introduction of the article by basically saying what the article's
about. What were the authors studying and why? What did they expect to
find (i.e., what were the hypotheses of the authors)? Then sketch
over the basic methods. How did they measure what they were studying? What
type of population (abused kids, adults with a disease, college students,
rats, etc.) were they studying?
For the results section, there is no need to describe the specific statistical
techniques used. You can if you want to and are knowledgeable about such
things, but the average student has yet to be exposed to these issues,
so don't worry about it. You should have an idea of is what the authors
were comparing or measuring or correlating or whatever. That is, how did
they test those hypotheses (not what specific tests, like t-tests
or ANOVAs or whatever; another language, isn't it?)? For example,
if they were studying whether kids or adults were better at video games,
you could say the authors had kids and adults play some video games and
they compared their performance on them by seeing which group got a higher
average score.
Finally, for the discussion section you report whether these results supported
or failed to support the authors' hypotheses. The authors may draw conclusions
about why they got the results they did. They often describe limitations
of the research, and suggest paths for future research. Summarize these
and form your own opinions if you like.
V. Proofreading, Printing, Handing in the Summary and Dealing with
Feedback
Finally, you are not done once you've typed the final word of
your summary. You've written a first draft. Read over your summary. Spell
check it with whatever computer program you have, but re-read it afterward
to catch other spelling errors (like when you misspell "too"
for "two") and grammatical mistakes. Read the summary out loud
slowly. Does it make sense? If you read it to your roommate would they
understand it? Try it out and see. Correct errors, making sure to save
your document occasionally (never wait until it'd done to save it
for the first time; that can be an awful lesson to learn first-hand!).
Don't use ridiculously large font sizes or margins to make your paper look
bigger. If anything, it looks smaller because of the huge font size or
margins and all that blank white space on the paper. Double space the type,
not triple (and not single) space.
Once you've gotten it to where you think it's perfect (naturally it's not,
but we typically think it is when we hand it in), print it out. Preferably
it should be printed out at least one day before it's due. Save it to the
hard drive if you can and to a floppy disk or two, in case for some mysterious
reason the printer does something strange as you try to print. If that's
the case you have time to find another machine on campus that will allow
you to print it correctly. Don't come to class and say you couldn't print
it but it's done. Your job is to hand in a completed summary by that time
and date; allow yourself time in case of technical difficulties.
The papers are due at class time on the date on your syllabus. Hand it
in on time. Make sure your name is on the paper. Paper clip or staple the
pages together ahead of time. I don't typically carry a stapler around
with me anymore than you do. And don't forget to include the first page
of the article you're summarizing when you hand in the paper.
When you get the paper back, look naturally at the grade, but also look
through the comments on the paper. Keep the paper handy for the next article
summary so you can learn from your mistakes. Remember that you can ask
me when comments are unclear or you don't understand why you didn't do
as well as you thought you should. And ask for advice on how to do better
next time.
Reading and writing are skills we continue to develop throughout our education,
and even beyond. So use this opportunity to practice these skills at the
college level so that you can excel not only in your classes, but when
you enter the job market and are called upon to read or write reports or
even summarize something in an oral presentation. These skills generalize
beyond the General Psychology course, so be diligent in trying to hone
them, and they will prove useful to you.